Example 5: Road management
Last Updated On: Sat Aug 29 2026Statement
Should parking be prohibited on narrow market roads?
Arguments
- Yes. Parked vehicles can block emergency services and worsen traffic congestion.
- No. Drivers enjoy parking close to shops.
Answer
Only argument 1 is strong.
Solution
- Argument 1 considers traffic flow and emergency access, both important public effects.
- Argument 2 is a convenience preference that does not outweigh the central concern.